I think this theme is pretty nice, has a lot of potential. My only nit-pick with it is mouseover animations (well the lack of them) for the various controls. (Noticing on scrollbars and buttons anyway) Other than that, it's pretty stylish without being gaudy/over-the-top. Looks great. A couple minor tweaks will make it perfect. Still a good vote from me.

Personally, the only part I think looks saturated is the highlight on menus. It would look nicer as a flat, even tone like the scroll bars are. I'd also like the option of a metacity theme in which the exit button is another color. Red would be nice, but would look too much like a certain other OS. Maybe black? That's my $0.02.

I really like this theme HOWEVER, its a bit too saturated. If you could take the saturation down just a notch, I would make it my default. maybe if the menu arrows were a little more subtle as well overall great look, I love it